This is very unclear as the laws contradict themselves and can be confusing for the acting jury and judges that are present as they will get to choose whether they feel that it is just or not, which means that the outcome on similar cases can possibly have totally different outcomes as it would be opinionated.
We will write a custom essay sample on Murder Essay or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not Waste HIRE WRITER The government have also acknowledged the fat that the law of murder needs to become a statute law, they have also asked the law commissions to research this area so that they can produce a report on the possible reforms.
Now looking at all the criticisms we see that there is a lot that can be done to improve the law regarding murder and it has been suggested that murder should be divided into two separate offences; First degree murder — which would be the intention to kill and would carry out the life sentence.
Even the judges are unclear as they tend to adjust it from one case to another. Yet even with the many treatments of the murders, the story remains obscure nearly a century later. Taken into custody following their crime, the suspects provided a detailed account of the chronology of the attack, omitting no detail save that of the motive behind the crime.
The new law has proposed a new defence to law of Diminished Responsibility which they say should be satisfactory.
Visual and Cinematic Representations This thesis analyzes the structures employed in narrating the crime of the Papin sisters. This would then reform the problem that occurs with the mandatory life sentence being applicable to every murder sentence no matter how much gruesome or truthful it may be.
Judges should be allowed to be given more authority when depending on the circumstances on the case for them to think of an appropriate sentence.
Through the lens of each writer, the crime has taken on a different shape, the sisters either psychotics, revolutionaries, lesbians or victims themselves.
In loss of control sexual infidalilty should not be included when looking at loss of control, this is absurd as the jealousy and anger which comes from sexual infidaility would technically cause loss of control, but this factor is told to be ignored.
The terms that are used in some of the elements in diminished responsibility are said that they should no longer be needed as the definition says it all. It says that loss of control includes the objective test which is actually meant to be subjective test which means that it is not greatly improved.
Loss of control is also a new law which is an updated version of the defence that used to be available to murder which was Provocation. All rights reserved by the author. Table of Contents Introduction: Testimony of the Papin Sisters Killer as divided subject First version of the crime Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.
A big problem regarding the law of murder is the actus reus. Murder is a common law offence which means the law is made due to the cases however, it should be written down which means it would then be a statute law, which was suggested by Lord Coke in the 15th Century.
Criminal law In this essay I will be criticising the law on murder including voluntary manslaughter and suggesting how it can be unsatisfactory as it can be quite confusing for the people who need to be applying the sentence for example the jury. A trial judge cannot even tell the difference between the different kinds of murder when imposing the sentence.
The questions that arouse are not what the law commissions intended to say.
What becomes apparent in this analysis is that the stringent logical form of narrative must be abandoned before the story of this murder can begin to be comprehended.
This would be help the people who are in desperate need to be taken out of all the suffering and hurt they are going through. Hogan wanted each case to be looked at separately and not compared which suggests that case law would then be demolished. People such as the jury who are not lay people may only understand bits of the law or not at all which can then result in a wrong verdict being given.
The first chapter examines three traditional detective narratives by Edgar Allan Poe, Gaston Leroux and Guy de Maupassant, mapping out expectations that are set up and resolved in the text.
This murder case challenges the facile solutions to crime provided in fiction, as traditional narrative means prove futile in explaining the story. Due to this one missing element, the murders have sparked a number of literary, cinematic and dramatic representations in the years following the crime, each trying to resolve questions around the disturbing murders.
The major criticism is regarding the mandatory life sentence, this is criticised by both law professionals and the law commissions.Dec 07, · Check out our top Free Essays on Narrative Essay About Murder to help you write your own Essay. Violence may murder the murderer, but it doesn’t murder murder.
Violence may murder the liar, but it doesn’t murder lie; it doesn’t establish truth. Violence may even murder the dishonest man, but it doesn’t murder dishonesty.
English Narrative essay Murder is the unlawful killing of another human being with malice afterthought, and generally this state of mind distinguishes murder from other forms of unlawful homicide (such as manslaughter).
Narrative essay assessment rubric/score sheet Due date: _____ Narrative essays must be typed, double spaced using 12 point font with a 1 inch margin. Headings must be left justified and include name, class period, title and. Abstract Written in Blood: The Murder Narrative and the Crime of the Papin Sisters By Julia E.
House On February 2,Christine and Léa Papin, two maids in Le Mans, France, attacked and brutally murdered their employers, Madame and Mademoiselle Lancelin. The victims' faces were beaten and slashed beyond all recognition, their legs.
Committing Murder The problem with committing murder is the high risk of being caught. When you decide that murder is justified, the problem of how to do it and how to avoid .Download